Topic: How long to write a song

How much time do you spend writing a song, do you keep revisiting? As I like to write about current topics, like the migrant crisis, politics (yawn) or just a protest song. I find that I have to lay the lyrics down in one sitting of not more than a couple of hours. I tend to find if I leave a song, lets say overnight, I've lost the thread, the mood has changed. And I just end up with a few lines in a scrapbook.
I would be interested to know how long you take over your songwriting.

Thick as two short planks

Re: How long to write a song

Gidday Real

I write & record the whole thing in 5 mins.I only do 1 take.
Don`t know where it comes from or how it happens.
I don`t know how or whats going to happen when i turn on the recorder.
It`s real seat of the pants stuff, but it`s the way i do it.
I find it pretty exciting though.

The King Of Audio Torture

Re: How long to write a song

I've got songs I've written in less than an hour and others that have taken months.  Most of my songs are in the tradition of Appalachian story tellers.  If a story can be told quickly then it doesn't take long.  I've sometimes spent months researching info for some of my songs. Sometimes  I've  written down an idea and came back to it years later.  I think my record is around 20 minutes for my fastest song and I've also got one that I wrote nearly 20 years after I got the original idea.  For me the key to writing a good song is in the re-write - taking out unneeded words or substituting better words, adding a bridge if necessary, etc, trying to make it as simple as I can without losing the vision I originally had for the song.  Sometimes I'll play a song dozens of times, making slight corrections until I'm satisfied with the tempo, meter, clarity and overall prosody of the lyrics and music.

Saturday evening I'm being featured in a songwriter's showcase, playing 90 minutes of my original songs.  I've been working on my playlist for weeks, trying to decide which of my songs to play, how to space out various types of songs and how to approach the whole evening.  I plan to end the set with 3 songs that were written several years after forming the original idea.

At various times I've spoken or performed for some fairly large groups of people and am usually pretty relaxed, but I have to admit I'm pretty nervous about this event. I've never done a solo gig in which the entire 90 minutes is playing only my original work. Have any other Chordians done this? How did you handle it?

DE

I want to read my own water, choose my own path, write my own songs

Re: How long to write a song

I have to add here that after recently spending a weekend listening (and playing along) to Ed's songs, that he does write some thought provoking and some very amusing songs.

As for me, I write some quickly and others are worked on for ages, although I have not completed anything for ages. I must make time to get something finished, but since retiring I seem to have far less free time on my hands.

Roger

"Do, or do not; there is no try"

Re: How long to write a song

I've written quite a few songs and found all these comments are true to all of my songs. Some fly onto the paper and others are painstakingly crafted to my satisfaction. I envy all of you who can sit down and create a work of art in one sitting as I've only done that a few times. And I also have pages of unfinished songs and future lines to use. It's all about the creative spirit that comes about to put these sweet tales together. I love the whole process anyway.I think it shows there is no set rules for writing a song. It's what ever process it takes as long as you finish it some time, and share it. It's all about sharing it, hoping someone will connect with the idea.
   Ed, since you wrote the songs you are to preform you can tell the stories better than anyone. If you had the passion to write them I think that passion will carry thru the performance too. Enjoy the experience and just have fun.
To all the rest keep writing, enjoy that experience.


Joe

Re: How long to write a song

of late i've come up with a line or two and maybe a bit of a tune. i may return later that day or next day with a different tune or rhythm. i find that doing one verse today and the chorus tomorrow stops the song being the same thing all the way through. i then try and stick to 3 verses a chorus repeated several times and if i can think of one a bridge or middle 8 as we used to call it. digging bits of failed songs from my scrap book helps when i get stuck.

Ask not what Chordie can do for you, but what you can do for Chordie.

Re: How long to write a song

Tyson7 wrote:

.
   Ed, since you wrote the songs you are to preform you can tell the stories better than anyone. If you had the passion to write them I think that passion will carry thru the performance too. Enjoy the experience and just have fun.


Joe

Excellent response Tyson.  By far some of the best advice I've ever received about playing my songs.  Thanks

DE

I want to read my own water, choose my own path, write my own songs