Here's the article from Rolling Stone - along with the recorded versions of both songs: http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/ … m-20160608
IMHO - they are different songs. Yeah, the have a similar sound. They aren't telling the same story. The hook isn't the same. They just have similar sounds and phrasing. I don't consider that plagiarism. Then again, I'm not a lawyer.
My Little Pony. I remember when I was little and I was sooooo into those toys and shows on TV. I remember having a "bright idea" that they should make Unicorn and Pegasus and maybe even Pega-Corns! They did. I remember (at the ripe old age of 7) thinking that I should have sent them a letter to suggest it so they'd send me money or free toys when they used my idea. LOL! Yeah, that would be a suggestion not a stolen idea, but what did I know? Moral of the story? Sometimes, I think it's adults with the mentality of a 7 year old that think up lawsuits. Sadly, they sometimes win too and it's their fault there are so many laws and regulations that really shouldn't have to be in place. Sigh...
Now, if it were one of my (few) songs, I would appreciate (and expect) being credited with the "sound" as an inspiration. I probably would be upset if i thought they stole a sound I had created (even if they totally changed the words). So, I get it. But honestly, if they just credited my sound as the inspiration I'd be happy - because they've CHANGED it to be a different song entirely. Again, I don't consider this plagiarism. It's not a stolen song through and through. That said, it certainly COULD have been an original idea on both sides that just happened to have the same sound. There are MORE than a few songs out there in the world with a similar sound, chord progression, phrasing, etc.
"What I'm pointing out is what might at first glance may appear to be plagiarism may turn out to be chance ,after all imitation must be the sincerest form of flattery or there wouldn't be so many " tribute" acts about ." AGREED GRAHAM!