26

(19 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Hey Badeye.
Just thought I'd toss a couple more in the hat for variety. I play all kinds of different stuff but lately have been working on some Ben Harper. I love "Diamonds on the Inside" and "She's Only Happy in the Sun" (mainly because my girlfriend loves these, but also because they're great tunes and fairly easy to play in terms of their chords. Its the tempo, cadence and emotion that really makes them outstanding.
Here's a YouTube link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTM3THD9 … re=related
The songs can be found in Chordie too, so its all good!

27

(5 replies, posted in Acoustic)

So it sounds to me that you are trying to learn the chords and the tab at the same time. No doubt this is confusing. I suggest that every tune in here you want to play you first look at the little chord chart at the top right and determine if you know those chords or not. If not then you need to practice chording before you try playing and learn those chords. Use the song to give you a sense of whether or not you've learned the chords, but don't worry about the tab stuff yet.
Those letters above the words are the chords to be played, but a word of caution; many songs here are not very accurate in either the chords given or the locations of those chords throughout the song. I have spent many an hour editing songs in my own song book to fix this, so it can be a little confusing for a beginner too. You might want to consider buying song books in the series called "made easy for guitar" with songs you already know how they "should" sound. I did this with several books while I was learning and it really helps to teach you the chords. Also, get yourself a good chord chart. There's a good one in here, but being an old timer now I guess, I still like the chord chart book I bought several years ago that is slim enough to fit in the neck portion of my guitar case.
Now, after more than 20 years of practice, I know many chords and can hear when there's one or two off and can fix it, but starting out I think you might get sidetracked too much by that.
Oh, and never forget - practice, practice, practice!

28

(16 replies, posted in Acoustic)

suckybeginner - I didn't catch how long you've been playing, but here's my thoughts on your issue.
First is that even a really good guitar sounds bad if you're not playing it at least half decently, and a pretty crappy guitar can be made to sound pretty nice by a really good player. So how is the beginner to decide what to go for in a new guitar?

Well I have been playing for over 20 years and have had many guitars in that time. Currently I have 5 guitars and one of my favorites is the Ibanez PF-10 that I bought for about $250 when I was learning. Maybe I got lucky, but that guitar has just never let me down. When I was shopping I compared it to more expensive guitars and many guitars that people told me were "better" but after a good couple of weeks of looking at and trying other guitars I kept coming back to that Ibanez. Does that mean every beginner should get a low cost Ibanez? No, of course not. But every beginner should get advice from someone unbiased (ie. not the salesman, although some salesmen are great) and should take their time in selecting a new guitar.

This is important because if you make a bad choice, in my experience nothing will discourage learning more quickly that a guitar that takes way too much skill to get a decent sound out of.

These days there are several really nice, low cost guitars available. Personally I don't care for the Seagull because I find them too stiff, but Samich, Takamine and Ibanez are all good choices. I think Fender has come to rely on their name a little too much and allowed quality to slip in the lower end of their market, Yamaha I am not too familiar with but they do make some really fantastic sounding guitars.

In the end, buy for the action and feel of the guitar, not the looks and if you're a beginner don't get into thinking too much about the sound. What's most important is the action and feel - sound will come later. Like I said, there are several good choices available in your $300 price range. Also, it could be that the Takamine you bought is fine but you haven't adjusted to it yet. I know that each of my guitars plays a little differently and I have to make certain adjustments to my fingering depending on which one I am playing, so that's worth considering too.

I guess now you have to convince the parents that you need to reconsider your first choice... maybe.
Good luck.

29

(26 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Hey again.

Just so you - and everyone reading knows, no offence was taken at all. I hope that the end result of this discussion is that people in the market for a new guitar will have some good things to think about before putting their cash on the counter.

By the way, I'd like to add that I've had some very expensive guitars and some pretty inexpensive ones too. The only one I've kept through it all is an Ibanez PF-10 that I bought about 20 years ago brand new for about $250 Canadian. It was all set up and ready to play right off the shelf and it has never required any tinkering or adjustments. The action and intonation is as good now as it was 20 years ago and it has been through the party, pub gigs, and travelling around scene. If anything it sounds better with age. Maybe I'm a tad sentimental about it, but the reality is that when I think about the couple hundred I could get for it today it's worth so much more to me than that. My most recent buy was the Takamine (thus my user name). I bought it through an ebay dealer who set it up before shipping and included the 9v battery for the on board electronics - all included in the price which, after shipping was still about $25.00 cheaper than the 3 different shops I checked. There is of course some risk when buying from ebay - caveat emptor - but I am very happy with this guitar for the money.

Come to think of it, we're probably making the new buyer's decision even tougher - ther is a lot to consider. In the end just be happy and make music.

30

(26 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Good points. I do not profess to be an expert, however I have bought and sold many guitars over the years. I have had good ones and bad ones - some that seemed like bargains until you found out the depth of the problems. Through it all I have learned a lot of valuable lessons and based on that my advice to the average guy or gal looking for a new guitar is to stay away from anything requiring much more than tuning if what you want is just to play. As for buying from a dealer I find that it is a competative industry and if the shop you're in isn't willing to put a ready to play product in your hands simply be aware that there are many very good, reputable and sincere dealers who value your business and their reputation enoug that they will. I have had a few "project" bargains as well and enjoyed working on them for the sake of it and enjoyed playing them afterwards, but that is an entirely different thing from looking to buy a new guitar from a store or dealer. My advice - get the most for your money that is available. To me that includes a properly set up guitar.

31

(6 replies, posted in Acoustic)

All good answers, however..... You said you can play right handed although not so well just yet - you also say you just learned and are predominantly left handed. Could it be that you're somewhat ambidextrous and, although it may be a little more challenging, if you do persist you could play right handed?

Just a thought. If you can do it right handed - bearing in mind that the guitar world caters mainly to right handed players - it might be worth you while to stick with it right handed.

Either way - good luck!

32

(16 replies, posted in Acoustic)

If you like some celtic/irish type stuff you can have some picking fun with Whiskey in the jar (I like Evans & Doherty's version, but apply finger picking to it) or Out on the mira - same deal - McGinty, Anne Murray or Cricklewood have good versions. On a different tack try Fleetwood Mac's Leather and Lace - nice!

Cheers - I'd love to hear you play them.

33

(8 replies, posted in Acoustic)

I agree with these guys saying to not forget the importance of lyrics - so true. I also must say I like the exercise of trying to answer such a question because it brings me back to thinking about something I no longer think much about. I've recently been playing Cat Stevens a lot - Peace train, Moonshadow, Father and son - you want to talk about challenging strum patterns. But I find if I disect the song one little piece at a time, I can then put it all together. I listen to the tune on CD or media player which allows me to listen to a short bit and then pause it. Then try to get just that short bit and move on to the next little bit. It takes some time, but I can usually get the hang of a new song all in one piece after a couple of days playing with it like that. I once had a student who's problem was strumming - in particular it was the smooth transition from one chord to the next that troubled her. The result was choppy playing that was really tough to keep time and rythem with. I got her to think about the root of each chord rather than the whole chord at once and focus on that. This eventually led her into double fingering and smooth strumming since focusing on the root allowed her fingers time to get in place for the whole chord and also eliminated her playing strings that were not part of that particular chord. That might be all a little off track for you, but it's another way to approach strumming. Above all keep practicing. The timing will come.

34

(26 replies, posted in Acoustic)

I have bought and sold quite a number of guitars over the years and I like the comments some have made here about shopping around both new and used. As for setting it up that depends on the action and intonation. Never buy a guitar just because you love the looks of the thing. If the action is good and it is properly tuned but still doesn't sound right I'd stay away unless you want to take your new guitar in to the shop for repair before ever getting any enjoyment out of it. If it has cracks in the area of the bridge, yeah, it can be repaired but its usaully a sign of an amature playing around with the steel rod that runs up the neck and over torsioning it - stay away from that too. Personally I like a new guitar to be set up properly before it ever gets to the shelf. It shows the manufacturer and dealer pay attention to the details and are probably reputable. Any dealer putting guitars out for sale that are not set up either didn't take the time to do it or don't know how. In my opinion neither of those are good. A good dealer knows his/her stuff and the guitar will be ready to play once you get it home and fine tune the tuning. Combine that with nice sound and good looks and you have a winning combination.