26

(49 replies, posted in Electric)

Only you can define what 'best' means for you.
Here are the stages you may pass through on the way to discovering what is best for your style:
1. You play what you have and barring any major problem, you are okay with that guitar.
2. At some point, you play someone else's really good guitar and it changes you idea about what a guitar should be.
3. You start shopping for better and better guitars and move through several in a short period.
4. You finally break down and order your 'ultimate' custom guitar with every feature known to man.
5. You play somebody's vintage guitar and it changes your idea about what a guitar should be.
6. You collect a number of old guitars, one for each job - jangle, crunch, bell-like clean tones and so on.
7. Finally, you notice that most of your collection is gathering dust because you tend to reach for that one go-to guitar that works for your individual style.

27

(3 replies, posted in Electric)

First, the key difference:
We all learn strumming early on, because it makes sense when playing alone. You can strum a simple song, sing along and get a decent result. As skills progress, you find that regular strumming does not fit very well into an arrangement or mix of other instrument. It takes up a lot of aural space for the interest if provides. An electric guitar greatly extends the possibilities, since the extra volume allows us to play almost anything, even subtle little lines and still hang in mix with horns, drums and so on.

Next, here are a few variations that you might try:

1. Thrumming power chords - using just the heaviest 3 strings, play all downstrokes on some simple power chords, keeping good time. For instance, Pachelbel's canon in D is a natural for this kind exercise: D, A, Bmin, G, D, G, A, etc. Try it with just a smidge of overdrive and palm-muting for cool thumpa-thumpa tone.

2. Ska skanking - using the bridge pickup and a thin, clean tone, try some quick up strokes on off beats, on the skinny strings. Something like "Watching the detectives". Amin, F, Amin, F, C, G, C, G, etc

3. Some U2 style 'scubbing' using a bright tone with a little delay. "In the name of love (pride)" is a good example. Or you could try a descending riff, like in "Just like heaven" by the Cure. It perofrms the same duty as a strumming pattern for keeping time, but takes up less space in the mix, since it is a single note run.

4. Lastly, try some hybrid picking. Hold a pick normally but add in fingerpicking using your ring and middle fingers. This is popular in country music and really makes basic chords sound nice. You will also hear it in everything from Beatles tunes to alternative.

28

(3 replies, posted in Electric)

They certainly look like your garden-variety barre chords / power chords. Basically like E and A in the first position, but with a bar across all the strings for use higher up the neck (barre chords), like using your index finger as a capo. Then you discover that you often only use the 2 or 3 lowest notes, so you can leave out the other notes (power chords). Essential for almost all rock songs.

29

(6 replies, posted in Electric)

Actually, once you get the hang of the technique, you can do it on an acoustic. Distortion just helps the wild, high insect noises really pop out.

.11's for me. Fender super bullets (stainless) on Fender scale (25.5") with single coils and DR pure nickle on Gibson scale (24.75") with humbuckers.

31

(6 replies, posted in Electric)

I suspect you are thinking of feedback. You often hear it at the end of a sustained note. It happens when the amp is loud enough to cause a feedback loop through the guitar body and pickups. You can accomplish this at somewhat lower volumes by touching the headstock to the speaker cabinet as a note sustains. Lots of preamp gain will also make controlled feedback easier to get.

Alternately, you may be hearing 'false harmonics' like in many ZZ Top recordings. This is accomplished by choking up on the pick so that only a little of it sticks out between your fingers and thumb. When you pick, allow the flesh of yoru thumb to follow the pick and just brush the string. With a gainy tone, this will generate crazy harmonic tones that will be one or even two octaves above the fretted note. At times, the tone is not even musically related to the fretted note.

32

(16 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

How about a baby Taylor:
http://www.taylorguitars.com/Guitars/Baby-Taylor/BT1/

33

(7 replies, posted in Electric)

Triple the output, I'd guess. Lipstick pickups are low output single coils with about 6k ohms of windings and Alinco II magnets. Ibanez has some different humbuckers,  including one sort of vintage model (58), but most are pretty warm. Esp. those on the pointier guitars.

34

(7 replies, posted in Electric)

What follows is just one person's opinion. Your milage may vary.

So, regular passive pickups have coils of fine wire and either magnets as 'slugs' below the strings or metal slugs/screws with a bar magnet beneath them. When the metal string moves through the magnetic field, a small AC voltage is induced into the coils and out to the amp. To make enough signal, the magnets need to be strong (but if they are too strong, they damp string vibration) and the coils need to have many, many winds of wire. This gives them a fair amount of self-capacitence and inductance. An inductor and capacitor wired together makes a low pass filter. In other words, it blocks high frequencies. That is why hot passive pickups, with Alnico magnets can sound dull. Ceramic magnets are brighter (though with more ragged midrange) and so are oftern used on hot pickups.

Active pickups have many fewer turns of wire and weak little magnets. The signal is tiny, so a solid state preamp is built right in to the pickup, to boost the signal. That is why they require a battery. Since they have less wire and less inductance, they reproduce highs very easily. Also the preamp gives them a really hot output, compared to a passive pickup.

So, to vintage geezers like me, good quality passive pickups are the real deal. Making them is an art. For a younger, metal oriented player, getting enough output, bright highs and clear, fat midrange from a passive pickup is almost impossible. That is where the active pickups come in. They are also popular for certain super-clean tones. EMG is best known for their active pickups. In that area, they are the industry leader.

Meanwhile, in an attempt to make more profit, they have started making a whole line of budget priced passive pickups. These passive pickups are low quality units that play on the popular EMG name and are used for entry level metal guitars. They have nothing in common with the active units. If a metal guy wanted to use passive pickuos, he would be better off with Rockfields, Tone Riders, Bill Lawrence, Duncans or any of several other brands.

35

(7 replies, posted in Electric)

EMG has multiple lines of pickups. The popular ones, the ones they are known for, are active. The 81 and 85 are active, use a battery and are widely used for teh metalz. They also have a variety of, cheaper, passive pickups that sound like typical budget models.

36

(2 replies, posted in Electric)

Original PAF's are rare and expensive.
Have you considered a vintage 'patent sticker' Gibson humbucker? They were probably the pickups that guitar shipped with - PAF's were more common on early 60's instrument. They can be had for a fraction of the cost.

If you are not restoring the instrument for investment purposes, but to play, try a set of Gibson '57 Classics, Burstbuckers or a set of Seymour Duncan Seth Lover humbuckers (!) or Antiquity HB's. The Dimarzio is far below the pedigree of that guitar.

37

(5 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

I have repaired lots of my own guitars and built a number of them from scratch, but I would take an investment grade instrument to a skilled luthier. Repairing valuable instruments is similar to restoring fine art. A proper repair has little to no impact on value. A poorly executed repair greatly reduces market value.

This guy is an expert or repairing vintage Martins:
http://www.frets.com/FRETSPages/pagelist.html

While a new side might be required, many side cracks can be repaired with a silk, linen or parchment patch, soaked in instrument grade hide glue applied to the inside. The external void can be filled with a lacquer stick, color matched to the wood. These steps are 1. compatible with the original materials and 2. reversible should other work be required.

38

(4 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

Has anyone else had trouble with Elixirs on electric guitars? I have them on my acoustic and like them a lot. When I put a set on a solidbody electric, I developed a grounding issue. Most electrics have the bridge tied in to the signal ground, which means the strings are at ground potential, to prevent shocks and stop noise. The coating on the Elixirs prevented the strings from making a good ground connection with my TOM bridge, so the guitar sounded really noisey through an amp. Switching to a noncoated string did the trick. Now I use DR pure nickle on my electrics with great results.

If it were me, I would want to try several in my price range. No matter the brand, I would want a guitar that sounds fairly loud and clear unplugged, with a neck profile that feels good in my hand and that will play in tune. I could always update the pickups, for different tones, but the neck is the heart of the beast.

As for amps, I would look for a good clean tone, at the loudest volume that I would generally need. There are lots of ways to get distorted tones (pedals, modeling,etc) but you can not add headroom. If an amp breaks up too soon, all you can do is shop for another model with more wattage.

40

(9 replies, posted in Electric)

I've been pleased with the Agile LP lookalike I bought recently. Close examination reveals where they cut corners - maple veneer on the top, thin rosewood on the fretboard and so on, but they play very well, are put together well and an excellent value. I also have an Epi LP (goldtop with P90's - '56 reissue) and the Agile is as good for a lot less money. Both needed new pickups and selector switches but that is easy to do and results are worth it.

41

(16 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

I do not think poly finishes will ever get the tiny cracks ("crazing") that old nitro finishes get. I also doubt that the cracks themselves are the source of any tonal improvement. They are just a sign that the finish has shrunk and hardened to a very thin, glass-like state that is less able to resist vibration. Poly finishes, like marine or spar varnish, skin over but remain pliable on the inside and so damp more vibration. The film is much thicker too.

That said, I don't feel that the finish is even in the top 5 of things that make one guitar sound better than another. For a solidbody, pickups have to be near the top of the list along with the specific stick of wood. The different species definately bring their own color to your tone. Even between parts made from the same species there are major differences in density and resonance. If you build a guitar from scratch, as you begin 'tap tuning' the parts, you will be amazed at the differences between say, 2 mahogany neck blanks.

Lastly, a guitar that feels really good inspires the player. The neck profile, fret finishing, fretboard radius, weight and hang all impact how a guitar feels. That is why I say, when you decide on a model you like, try to play 10 or 12 of them to find the one that has that little bit of magic for you.

42

(16 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

One of the big differences is how even and regular the windings are. I think this is what the Gibson rep was trying to say. Most machine wound-pickup coils have very regular, even windings.

Some human-wound pickups have sloppier windings. Some are even "scatter wound" on purpose. This reduces the inductance slightly and increases the self-capacitance resulting in a different (higher) resonant frequency. In short, a scatter wound pickup will sound slightly brighter with a little less output that an evenly wound pickup, with the same amount of wire and the same magnets. Players report that these pickups sound more "hi-fi", glassy or crisp.

For instance, the pickups in SRV's main guitar were made by a notoriously sloppy worker at Fender. They were unintentionally scatter wound. Some shops now have machines that can reproduce this slightly random wrapping technique.

43

(6 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

Poly does not normally yellow with age, like lacquer. You can tint it, or dye the wood prior to finishing.

Some people have experimented with using strong UV, from a bed at a tanning salon, to age/color factory guitar finishes. Others wipe on brown shoe polish, then buff it off to leave a slight yellow tint.

44

(6 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

With the parts being made on the same CNC machines, there is only so much difference. I generally recommend that anyone shopping for a Fender, go to a place where they can try at least 12 of the same model. Now as in the old days, about one of 10 or 12 are really good. Others, not so much. Ignore color, point of origin and all that. Just look for the one that feels right, sounds loud and lively unplugged and holds tune. That said, some of the better ones I've tried lately were MIM 'standard' series and Highway One models.

45

(22 replies, posted in Electric)

My 12 year-old son plays a left-handed strat copy, but school makes him play cello right handed. All of the bows must move in the same direction, they say, to avoid collisions.

46

(16 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

California air quality laws strongly limits the use of spray finishes that contain a solvent that evaporates into the air, like lacquer.

Also, from an efficiency standpoint, lacquer must be sprayed in layers, over time, allowing the previous coat to fully skin over. Then it must be left to cure for 2- 4 weeks before the final polish can be done.

Traditional lacquer continues to dry and harden for years, shrinking and giving off solvent. That is why old guitars have cracks in the finish (it shrunk) and that is another reason why old guitars sound different.

Modern poly finishes, on the other hand, can be fully cured by 90 seconds of exposure to UV light.

47

(16 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

I am a bit of a vintage snob, I must admit. If you doubt the difference, play a 50's tele and a modern reissue back to back. You can't deny that those old guitars can play like butter and sound glorious. That said, I build guitars from modern parts or modifiy stock models to closely approximate the keys parts of that sound and feel. It can be done without tons of trouble.
One important part of the puzzle, after wood quality and pickups is the finish. After playing lacquer finished guitars for any length of time, modern poly finished guitars feel awful, plastic-y and cold. They sound muted and dead.

48

(275 replies, posted in Electric)

I turned 49 two days ago.

49

(7 replies, posted in Electric)

Do you know the radius of the fingerboard?
Lots of vintage guitars, with a small radius (7.5 - 9.5") will "fret out" on bent notes, esp. above the 12th fret. That is whay newer guitars have a larger radius (12") or a compound radius (12-16"). That gives you a flatter fretboard overall and with a compouond radius, it gets even flatter as you move up the neck. Though, first position chords are more comfortable on a smaller radius neck.

If I had to bet, I would guess that one of the higher frets was not properly dressed at the factory, or was not fully seated. If you see a fret (above the 18th) with a tiny visible gap between it and the board, you could try tapping it gently with a plastic headed hammer to seat it. If you sight down the neck, from the bridge end, and see a fret that is too high (proud), you can block sand it with 320, 400 & 600. That will make the top flat, so you'll need to re-round it with fine sand paper or synthetic steel wool without out a block.

50

(6 replies, posted in Electric)

One popular strategy for soloing over jazz tunes is, to play a line crafted from the notes of a chord when ascending but play through the notes from the scale when descending.

So if you were playing over a jazzy blues in Amin, you might play play an ascending line made up of notes from, say, an Amin7, 9 or 11 chord - this will naturally cause you to leave out some of the notes in the scale, resulting in an 'open' , angular line. Then, put your practice of scales to use by ripping through a chunk of the Amin scale (or Phrygian, or whatever) when descending, which will naturally provide extra "in between" notes, giving you more to play and make for a smoother transition from high to low notes.

You hear horn players do this a lot.