Topic: Pick trouble.......

Hi, This may seem daft but I just cannot strum with a pick without it turning around or coming away from my hand completely and flipping onto the floor. I don't know if it's the actual grip I use, taken from several guitar books or the motion of my strumming

It has been a real problem since day one, the dog even now waits for dad to flip the funny little frisbee so he can catch it.

Can someone help before I have to make a paving slab sized pick or pay the vet to retrieve it from the dogs' throat  <img src="images/smiley_icons/icon_confused.gif" border=0 alt="Confused">

Re: Pick trouble.......

hey sparra i too had similar problems. i got a top of an ice cream contianer and cut out a pick double the size of a pick.then i sanded it down to be thin on one end.this way i could get a better grip and not drop it every third or fourth strum. i used it for about a week then back to a regular pick and now i dont have that problem. i know a bit unorthadox but it worked for me. good luck hope this helps...badeye.

one caper after another

Re: Pick trouble.......

Hi Sparra, I Recommend you get yourself a light guage thumb pick.  they are exactly the same as a flat pick, except they have a loop typed thing on top to hold it on your thumb.you can still hold it like a regular flat pick, and it will not move. Hope that helps

DJ Cormier
[url=http://www.bigdjindustriez.tk]www.bigdjindustriez.tk[/url]
myspace.com/bigdjindustriez

Re: Pick trouble.......

We had this thread a while back, and I was suffering the same problem. Someone suggested a way of holdng the pick, which I can't remember how to describe, kind of between the index fingernail and the pad of the thumb. I haven't dropped a pick since, but wierdly, I no longer hold it in exactly that fashion, but it was a phase I went through which stopped me dropping the flipping pick!

Re: Pick trouble.......

i hold my pick between the side of my middle finger and my thumb, keeping it straight with my index finger

DJ Cormier
[url=http://www.bigdjindustriez.tk]www.bigdjindustriez.tk[/url]
myspace.com/bigdjindustriez

Re: Pick trouble.......

There are lots of options. Change the way you hold it, Change the type of pick(fender makes a very large triangle shaped pick), or just don't use one. Buddy Guy says useing a pick is like showerring with your shoes on. Good Luck.

                                     - Mike

"Nobody paints by ear so why would I play guitar by sight?" hmm

Re: Pick trouble.......

i use to burn a hole in it with a cigarette at the top,worked like a charm!

Re: Pick trouble.......

If it makes you feel better, I've seen some truly great players drop the pick in the tone hole every now and again.

Someday we'll win this thing...

[url=http://www.aclosesecond.com]www.aclosesecond.com[/url]

Re: Pick trouble.......

hey satman i like your idea with the cigarette.I started guitar because i quit smoking and needed to keep busy.I,m sure i can find another source of heat.LOL.my fingers are always busy on this six string.have a good one...Badeye.

one caper after another

Re: Pick trouble.......

I suffer from this problem too.  Everly actually makes a pick with the hole already in it, no burning required. <img src="images/smiley_icons/icon_smile.gif" border=0 alt="Smile">  Star Grip Picks.

Re: Pick trouble.......

cool, already burnt one,but will look to buy one...Badeye.

one caper after another

Re: Pick trouble.......

Why don't you people just get a light thumb pick? same deal as a pick, but it holds itself on.  Personally, my thumbnail is better than a pick, but if you need one, go for the thumb pick..or just hold it tighter.

DJ Cormier
[url=http://www.bigdjindustriez.tk]www.bigdjindustriez.tk[/url]
myspace.com/bigdjindustriez

Re: Pick trouble.......

That makes me fell better cause I still do that sometimes. <img src="images/smiley_icons/icon_redface.gif" border=0 alt="Embarassed">

"Nobody paints by ear so why would I play guitar by sight?" hmm

Re: Pick trouble.......

CONGRATS ON THE QUITTING SMOKING BADEYE,i quit 1 week and 4 days ago.

if it wasnt for the ole six gun laying around i would go out of my f_ _ _ _n mind. good luck on the pick.

Re: Pick trouble.......

<font color="crimson"></font><b></b><i></i>That's a question that will get you loads of opinions...different things work for different people and apparently there is no absolute on right or wrong... for most of my stuff I use a heavy thumb pick and three fingers. I thought that if it worked for Chet Atkins and Jerry Reed then it's good for me. I also use a heavy flat pick. Hold the pick very loosely for strumming...the looser the better...yes, you will drop it a lot but with lots of practice it'll become part of you...then when you need to dig in for lead work or power chords, just grip tighter and go for it.  A lot of really outstanding Bluegrass Mandolin and Guitar players use a piece of tortise shell (now illegal to possess) about the size of a half dollar and almost as stiff!

Middleaged Redneck sorta guy who refuses to grow up...passion for music, especially Southern Rock but like bout everything cept Gangsta/Hip Hop. Collect guitars, mandolins, and love to ride Harleys.

Re: Pick trouble.......

Good luck Satman.the guitar will help.hagn in there it gets better.

...Badeye.

one caper after another

Re: Pick trouble.......

I found some good (and cheap) picks in my store. They are standard rounded edge triangels with a surface of small diamond shapes that gives it a sandpaper feel. This heavily reduses the picks urge to turn (and point to your knuckles insted of to your strings).


Unfortunately I don't now their name, and they are not marked with anything but thickness. A hint though is that they are colour coded, a speciffic thickness is alway the same colour (I bought a bunch of purple, black, orange etc. and tried out wich I liked best).


Another tip is to NOT let the pick stick out to much. The smaller part you stick out the lesser leverage the pick gets to twist out of your grip.

/Missen

If you love what you do, there's no need to be good at it...

Re: Pick trouble.......

Hey everyone,


I recall this thread from a while back.  The thing that stopped me dropping the pick was purely the way it was held. I read this online somewhere when I was learning the axe.


Bend your index finger under your thumb until the top segment of your finger is hidden by your thumb as though you were grabbing someones chubby cheeks.


This in efffect creates a loop.  The pick should now be able to sit between the underside of your thumb (ie the finger print bit)and the side of the top segment of your index finger.


Bloody hard to describe, I know.  The thing I found is that it was a bit like a golf grip, really unorthodox for a while but when your used to it, it feels natural.  The trick seems to be not to hold it as a 'pinch' whith the tips of your fingers....I just tried that then and it lasted about 3 strums.


Good thing is that it doesn't require much strength to hold on place, especially for thin picks, as the wide section of the pick it balanced so impact is spread across the entire pick width.


Hope this helps, if not, try summat else....

Re: Pick trouble.......

<table border="0" align="center" width="90%" cellpadding="3" cellspacing="1"><tr><td class="SmallText"><b>Hendo wrote on Thu, 22 March 2007 11&#58;45</b></td></tr><tr><td class="quote">
Hey everyone,


I recall this thread from a while back.  The thing that stopped me dropping the pick was purely the way it was held. I read this online somewhere when I was learning the axe.


Bend your index finger under your thumb until the top segment of your finger is hidden by your thumb as though you were grabbing someones chubby cheeks.


This in efffect creates a loop.  The pick should now be able to sit between the underside of your thumb (ie the finger print bit)and the side of the top segment of your index finger.


Bloody hard to describe, I know.  The thing I found is that it was a bit like a golf grip, really unorthodox for a while but when your used to it, it feels natural.  The trick seems to be not to hold it as a 'pinch' whith the tips of your fingers....I just tried that then and it lasted about 3 strums.


Good thing is that it doesn't require much strength to hold on place, especially for thin picks, as the wide section of the pick it balanced so impact is spread across the entire pick width.


Hope this helps, if not, try summat else....



</td></tr></table>


That's exactly what worked for me. Aother advantage of this technique is that you don't keep breaking your thumbnail, as I did when I tried playing whilst pinching the pick. As I play fingerstyle about half the time (now I can use a pick without smashing my nails), this was a real bummer and meant that I had actually given up on using a pick at all for fear of sullying my carefully cultivated snot scrapers.


<img src="images/smiley_icons/icon_smile.gif" border=0 alt="Smile">

Re: Pick trouble.......

Hi Sparra


I used to have the same problem until I found picks called Snarling Dogs Brain Picks.  They come in many different sizes and have a gritty feel to them.  You can usually find them at any guitar shop and work really well...I have not dropped a pick since I started using them.


Good luck!!