Hi Doc, haven't posted in your direction in awhile but you do come up with good ones....
You know the first "Les Paul" was built out of a 2"X4" piece of framing timber, with some pickups and a fretboard.... through the magic of electronics an awful lot of cool sound are made. But I tend to lean towards the acoustic, viewing the electronics as tools to enhance what is already there....
There are hill people in Cambodia (or whatever it is called this week) that can make beautiful music with two strings and a piece of bamboo lashed to a dried Ox bladder, that beats the pants off anything I can hope to attain with six strings and a custom carved slab of bubinga. So yeah, in some cases it does come down to the amps and effects.
For my money, skill and practice wins over everything!
Choose your guitar by it's sound, unplugged and plugged in... if it sings to your heart, and feels right in your hands, take it home and enjoy a long life together.
Take Care;
Doug